Among the evaluations of “A 20th-Century Girl” , there is a saying that it is “a stroke of genius.” However, using that phrase to explain all the merits of the film would be a mistake. While the actors certainly brought the characters to life, there was a compelling story about the girl that made their performances possible.
In 1999, Bora, who was 17 years old, received a request from her best friend, Yeondoo, to go to the United States for surgery. Yeondoo asked Bora to observe Hyunjin, a male student she liked. Bora became close to Hyunjin’s friend, Unho, and eventually realized her own feelings. She went to help her friend with her romance, but ended up dealing with her own. I think this is a good starting point. Bora doesn’t wait for someone to like her. Instead, she takes the initiative, often making mistakes, and then hesitates when faced with her own feelings.
What touched my heart most was that hesitation. The child, who was so cheerful when it came to her friends, was not being honest about her own feelings. She was trying to protect them, but hiding things doesn’t necessarily prevent her friends from getting hurt. The film is at its best when it addresses this discrepancy. However, the problem lies in the latter part. Understanding why a character cannot speak and accepting the explanations that the film omits are two different things.
I believed that Bora was hiding her feelings. However, I could not understand why the movie was delivering important news so late.
This is not a film that survived solely because of Kim Yu-jeong
I admire Bora’s choice, which came before the charm of Kim Yu-jeong. I appreciate the fact that the girl, who was brave in matters of other people’s love, becomes timid when it comes to her own love.
If Bora had liked Eunho from the beginning, the story would have been much simpler. It would have been a straightforward sequence of approaching the person she liked and hesitating because of a friend. However, in this movie, Bora is first motivated by her feelings for her friend.
Boram’s help is crucial for Yeondoo, who is going to the United States for heart surgery. Unable to see the boy she likes in person, she relies on her friend’s perspective. Boram accepts this request and tries to identify Hyun-jin.
At that time, for Bora, the boy’s actions were information to be shared with a friend. It is more important to consider how well she can help her friend than who she likes. Thanks to this approach, even when Bora is actively involved, she doesn’t come across as someone who is skilled in romance.
As Bora gets closer to Eunho, the meaning of the same actions changes. Her own feelings become involved in the process of getting to know someone in order to help a friend. Now, Bora is not just someone who can simply convey what she has learned.
While they are diligent in understanding the feelings of others, they are often slow to report on their own feelings.
I ended up supporting Bora here. My feelings for my friend are genuine, and my feelings for Eunho are also genuine. If one of those feelings were false, Bora’s worries wouldn’t be this painful.
The film does not simply portray Bora as the “good” friend. Bora must make a choice when actions intended to help others ultimately affect her. Being a good listener to a friend’s request and being honest with that friend are two different things.
This difference also gives the actor something to do. The initial exuberance is not simply a contrast to the subsequent hesitation; it is an integral part of the character. The habit of thinking of friends first can, depending on the situation, be both a source of courage and a cause for hesitation.
Bora’s tendency to postpone her own happiness also stems from this habit. While I do not agree with that choice, I understand why she makes it. Liking a character and believing that character’s judgment to be correct are two different things.
Therefore, simply praising Bora’s vitality overlooks the difficult choices presented in the film. Bora experiences a change in her feelings, becoming different, yet she also retains her affection for her friend, creating a dilemma. Does Bora, who hides her own feelings, become as trustworthy as the spirited Bora from the beginning?
Yunho, who is reserved in his speech, and Bora, who conceals her feelings, are different
Kim Yoo-jeong and Byeon Woo-seok portray different kinds of silence. Consequently, even with fewer lines of dialogue, the emotions between the two characters continue to evolve.
In the role of Bora, Kim Yoo-jeong portrays a girl who acts impulsively when responding to a friend’s request. In the initial stages of observing Hyun-jin, her actions are often ahead of her thoughts, but when she tries to conceal her feelings, her assertiveness diminishes. She is the type of person who readily steps in to help a friend, but hesitates to get involved in her own affairs.
Kim Yu-jeong does not portray the change as if Bora has suddenly become timid. While her assertive attitude remains, she hesitates when she is about to say what she needs to say. I felt more empathy for Bora when she, who was usually so assertive, hesitated in expressing her feelings.
The hesitation does not solely stem from feelings of affection for the other person. It also includes concerns about not wanting to hurt a friend. Kim Yu-jeong does not eliminate either of these feelings, which helps the reader understand Bora’s silence.
On the other hand, Woon-ho, played by Byeon Woo-seok, is originally a boy who is reserved in his speech. Even in the scenes where he becomes closer to Bora in the broadcasting club, he does not exaggerate his manner of speaking or actions. He calmly responds when Bora takes the initiative, adjusting the pace of their relationship.
That restraint is good. Because he doesn’t talk much, he doesn’t become a person whose true feelings are completely unknowable. His quiet demeanor towards Bora, filled with underlying interest, reveals his feelings without needing a grand declaration.
If both actors had expressed their emotions more overtly, Bora’s hesitation might have been less noticeable. Because Unho maintained a calm demeanor, the subtle shifts in Bora’s approach, moving closer and then retreating, were clearly visible. Even though the periods of silence were the same, the reasons why the two people were being reserved in their speech were not necessarily the same.
Park Jeong-woo plays Hyun-jin, a male student who is the subject of Bora’s observation. The humor arises when the confident and boastful Hyun-jin clashes with Bora, who is busy helping her friends. No Yun-seo’s character, Yeo-doo, stops the laughter after returning and demands honesty from Bora, something her friend needs.
Thanks to this nuance, Bora’s silence is no longer automatically interpreted as pure innocence. While the feelings that cannot be expressed to Eunho are poignant, the feelings hidden from Yeondoo raise questions. If the actors have managed to convey these emotions so convincingly, is it justifiable to dismiss this relationship simply because of a familiar misunderstanding?
The reasons for concealing information are more important than the anticipated misunderstandings
I agree with the criticism that it is easy to misinterpret. However, I do not agree with the assessment that this makes the conflict between Bora and Yeondoo predictable.
The misunderstanding that begins with a name tag is a convenient coincidence that can influence relationships. A small mistake in connecting a name with a face can stir the feelings of many people. For viewers who understand the situation before the characters do, this can be frustrating.
I do not necessarily consider the misunderstanding itself to be a brilliant plot twist. However, I also do not believe that the film’s entertainment value depends on the correct answer to that misunderstanding. The important thing is to see what Bora says after she understands the truth.
Silence when one doesn’t know something is different from silence when one knows but chooses to conceal it. The former is a mistake, while the latter is a deliberate choice. The point at which the film begins to hold Bora accountable is precisely here.
Bora puts her own feelings aside because she cares about her friend. She believes that Yeondu should not be hurt. However, this desire does not automatically make Bora’s choices right.
Bora believes that she can preserve their friendship by concealing her feelings. However, she unilaterally decides what is best for Yeondoo. Her actions are a mixture of wanting to help her friend and a lack of trust in her friend’s judgment.
While claiming to be considerate of friends, they fail to ask for their opinions. Consent from all parties is necessary, even in friendships.
Therefore, the scenes where Yeondoo and Borah interact are significant. Yeondoo is not a friend who intentionally obstructs Borah’s love. He is a person who is hurt by the fact that something related to him was done without his knowledge.
I understand Bora’s hesitation, but in this instance, I side with Yeondoo. Sometimes, it’s not about how much a friend has endured for me, but about what they have hidden from me, and that can be painful. Yeondoo’s reaction clearly highlights this difference.
The mere fact that someone develops feelings for the same person does not make anyone at fault. However, even after concealing those feelings, one should not expect the other person to be grateful. Even with Bora’s kind heart, there should still be a place for Yeondoo to feel disappointed.
From this perspective, the potential for misunderstanding is only the beginning of the conflict. A more difficult issue remains: how much honesty is appropriate to share with a friend. Even if one of the girls initially understands the correct answer, it does not mean that she has finished reading the choices made by both girls.
Then, will the movie, which explores the consequences of silence in friendships, maintain the same standard until the very end?
Records that convey feelings are truly effective
Using past footage to convey feelings that were previously unnoticed is a good choice. This film allows viewers to understand feelings that were left unexpressed at the time.
As Bora becomes an adult, she confronts videos from her past. What is important here is not just seeing her childhood face again, but also realizing that there were feelings she didn’t even know she had towards the people she remembers.
Bora was a person who concealed her feelings. Now, Bora realizes that she had feelings that she had not even revealed to the other person. Even though they spent the same time together, they did not necessarily know the same things.
I liked the way this difference was conveyed through video. If someone had described those feelings for me at the time, I would have had to believe what they said. Instead, I understand his feelings by seeing the image of Unho that remains in the video.
Although the past events depicted in the video remain the same, Bora, who is watching it, has changed. Bora, now, understands feelings that she did not recognize at the time. This is the reason why revisiting the past can evoke current emotions.
If the scene was simply about saying that the era was beautiful, I would have been less affected. Seeing a familiar face and understanding hidden feelings are different experiences. This film takes on a second role, that of a historical record.
Placing this film alongside the director’s short film, “Ms. Young-hee,” highlights the significance of this choice. In that work, a middle-aged woman encounters her son, who resembles her first love. Bringing past love into the present is what gives life to the story.
In the film “A 20th-Century Girl,” video recordings take on that role. While “Her Brother” focuses on encounters with people who resemble the protagonist, this film shows images from the past. What current individuals learn about past loves connects the two works.
I value the moment when Bora comes to understand Unho’s feelings, which were previously unknown to her. The feelings of the other person, which could not be known through Bora’s memories alone, are conveyed through records. The fact that something was not said does not necessarily mean that there were no feelings.
Therefore, I will not dismiss the feelings in this part as artificial. There is certainly power in Bora’s process of discovering feelings she was unaware of. However, the object used to convey those feelings is not necessarily excellent, and the explanation of how that object arrived is not entirely satisfactory.
In the early part, Bora gathers information about Hyeon-jin to share with her friend. In the final part, Bora receives the feelings of Un-ho that remain in the video. Initially, the child who recognized the love of others eventually comes to understand the love she has received. This is the reason why I was moved in the final video.
The last tear cannot fill the preceding blank space
I reacted to the final emotion, but I do not accept the explanation provided for that emotion. While Bora’s feelings are understandable, the circumstances by which such important news reached her so late are insufficient.
I will not disclose the details of the news. The problem is not the content of the news itself, but the process by which it reaches Bora. The film presents the result that Bora was unaware, but it does not sufficiently explain why she should have been unaware.
Of course, Bora doesn’t need to know everything. Even with people we were close to, we don’t know everything about their lives. After contact is lost, there is also a time for individual speculation and misunderstanding.
However, there is a difference between what a character doesn’t know and what a film doesn’t explain. If Bora didn’t receive the news, the film needs to at least show enough to make that disconnection believable. It’s not a demand to explain every detail, but rather a request to provide a foundation for understanding the emotions.
Previously, when Bora concealed her feelings from Yeondoo, there was a reason behind it. She did not want to hurt her friend, and this choice caused their relationship to become unstable. Both the reason for concealing her feelings and the consequences of that concealment were revealed.
In the latter half, the narrative loses its momentum. While the delayed news creates a strong emotional impact, the reason for the delay is not as clear. I found myself constantly being pulled back to the events that preceded the news, hindering my ability to fully immerse myself in Bora’s sorrow.
The sincerity of the feelings conveyed in the video is separate from this issue. The recording conveys a love that Bora was unaware of. However, it does not explain why that love was not expressed for so long.
Bang Woo-ri said, “We could not give up on the ending.” I understand where that stubbornness is coming from. My interpretation is that she did not want to end her first love as just a beautiful memory.
Even so, the determination to protect the ending cannot compensate for the lack of persuasiveness in the path leading to it. The more clearly defined the desired final scene, the more solid the preceding narrative must be.
The director is not obligated to answer audience questions or to explain a conclusion that they have not abandoned.
I don’t want to say that Bora’s love is cheap because of this blank space. I sympathize with the girl who hides her feelings in order to cherish her friend. However, I cannot understand the film’s omissions, even with empathy for that girl.
Now, the remaining question is whether it is worth spending time with Bora, despite her shortcomings.
Bora’s silence was understandable, but the film’s omissions were regrettable
My rating is 3.5 out of 5 stars. While the explanation in the latter half is lacking, the story is worth the time spent on Bora’s love and friendship. The process of the girl who was helping her friend’s love story coming to a halt in front of her own feelings is well-written. Bora is a protagonist who makes you understand why she made the wrong choices, even when she did.
The different chemistry between Kim Yoo-jeong and Byeon Woo-seok, and the sincerity of their friendship, were highly praised. The reason for the deduction is clear: the sadness overshadows the circumstances by which important news arrives late.
There is a reason why a character cannot speak. However, that reason cannot excuse the film for omitting explanations. The fact that the character’s feelings changed at the end does not negate the questions that were raised earlier.
If you enjoy stories that blend everyday life with first love and friendship, this is recommended. It is particularly suitable for audiences who are drawn to the story of a spirited girl discovering her own feelings. On the other hand, if you are expecting a lighthearted school romance from beginning to end, this may not be for you.
I would not readily recommend this film to audiences who demand a meticulously detailed explanation of the events and the circumstances surrounding them. The film effectively builds the emotional context, but it rushes through the explanation of the events. Whether viewers can accept this difference will determine their level of satisfaction.
When watching, you don’t have to focus as much on guessing who likes whom. Instead, pay attention to what Bora *doesn’t* say to whom, and the conflicts will become clearer. Yeondoo is also better understood as a friend who waits for honest words from her rivals.
Next, we will examine Bang U-ri’s short story, “Ms. Young-hee.” While the short story evokes past love through its characters, this film brings it to the present through its visuals. Comparing the two works side by side reveals the interesting way in which feelings discovered later in life can transform the present.
Bora nodded, acknowledging the feelings she had concealed, but a question remained regarding the underlying reasons hidden within the film.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is “20th Century Girl” based on a true story?
The film is based on a diary exchanged between a director and a real-life friend. However, it is important not to take all the events depicted in the film as factual. It is more accurate to view it as a fictional story about the friendship and first love of young girls.
Is the webtoon or the novel the original work?
This is not based on a webtoon or novel. It is a feature film adapted from director Bang Woo-ri’s short film, “Young-hee.” You do not need to have seen the short film to understand Bora’s story.
Is it a light and sweet youth romance?
In the early stages, the story brings laughter and excitement as it depicts helping a friend with their unrequited love. However, it does not maintain a lighthearted tone throughout. It deals with conflicts in friendship and heavy emotions, so those who are only looking for a bright and cheerful school romance may not find it suitable.
Where can you see it, and what should you know before viewing it?
This is a Netflix original series. The story is set in 1999 and follows Bora, who observes a male student at the request of a friend, and discovers her own feelings. The story is more engaging if you follow who Bora is hiding her feelings from, rather than focusing on the “right” way to be in a relationship.
Is it okay to watch it just to see the actors’ performances?
It is fine. Kim Yoo-jeong’s active behavior and Byeon Woo-seok’s calm manner of speaking create a contrast, which leads to changes in their relationship. However, I hope the drama also portrays the process in which Bora and Yeondoo clash due to their honesty, as much as it showcases the actors’ charm.