Film Review

Black Panther: Wakanda Forever (2022) Review: Grief is not a license for revenge

LUX · November 15, 2026

“It should have been shorter.” This complaint about “Black Panther: Wakanda Forever” only addresses half of the problem. It’s not a film that can be improved simply by reducing its length; rather, its quality depends on how the filmmakers choose to allocate screen time.

The 161 minutes were most wasted not on the time spent saying goodbye to the deceased King T’Challa. In the scene where T’Challa was being laid to rest, I wanted to see the faces of those left behind more than I wanted to see the next event. One cannot demand such a rapid pace even for a funeral.

The problem lies in the fact that the film constantly drifts away from the scientist, Shuri, who failed to save her brother. Whenever new characters and stories about the American intelligence agency are introduced, the person who truly deserves to be the focus is left waiting. While moments where Shuri struggles to cope with her grief are necessary, not everything, including the detours that momentarily distract her from that grief, is essential.

Even so, I support this film because it portrays Shuri’s anger not as something to be discarded, but as a process of preparing to gain strength. What is important is not the emergence of a new hero, but what a wounded person does to others. I believe that this film succeeds not in filling the role of a hero, but in helping those who remain find something to do other than seek revenge.

“The introduction of the next installment clashes with the memorial aspects of the film.” While this is a valid point, simply stating that there was a clash does not mean that the film’s attempt to honor the deceased was a failure. I believe that even when the focus shifted to the next story, the standard for portraying Shuri’s grief remained consistent throughout the film.

“Black Panther: Wakanda Forever” begins with a younger sibling unable to save her older brother. Shuri, a member of the Wakandan royal family and a scientist, desperately tries to save T’Challa but fails. In this opening, I was more concerned about how much the surviving characters would blame themselves than about when a new hero would appear.

However, the film repeatedly focuses on the student inventor Riri and the American intelligence operative Ross. The student Riri is essential for revealing the threat from the underwater kingdom. But not all of the subplots are as crucial to the story as Riri’s role.

However, the first question to ask about this movie is whether it distinguishes between sadness and the right to harm others. While understanding the pain of losing someone, does that mean we must accept even the violence they inflict? I believe this movie successfully avoids using sadness as a justification for revenge, but in trying to provide that answer, it also tries to cover too much ground, including setting up the next Marvel story.

Even if Chu-mo and Marvel clash, Chu-mo is not necessarily the loser

I agree with the criticism that the introduction of the next Marvel story clashes with the mourning. However, just because the side plot is annoying does not mean that the story about Shuri’s grief is a failure.

In the introduction, Shuri attempts to save her brother, T’Challa, using science, but fails. Even for her, a brilliant scientist, there are some things that cannot be fixed. This failure is not a matter that needs to be urgently addressed before a new hero emerges.

From this, I gained a standard by which to judge Shuri’s future choices. When a hand that wanted to save lives tries to harm someone, that change should not be simply supported. One must remember the desperation of the starting point in order to truly understand the danger of anger.

The guilt that Shuri feels for not being able to save her brother helps the audience understand her. However, this does not excuse all of his future actions. The film does not simply portray Shuri as a pitiable character, but rather as someone who must make choices about her own behavior.

That is precisely why Shuri needs more time. It is not about repeatedly explaining that she is sad. It is about needing time to understand how her sadness affects her behavior, who she directs her anger towards, and what demands she is vulnerable to.

However, the film frequently shifts focus between the student inventor Riri and the American intelligence operative Ross. Riri’s storyline is connected to the reasons why the underwater kingdom is making demands on the surface world. On the other hand, Ross’s storyline carries a greater burden, as it deviates from Shuri’s choices.

Introducing new characters is not inherently wrong. However, when a character is burdened with tasks that they cannot handle, the film shifts its focus to other matters. It is not the character who is at fault, but rather the film that forces him to wait.

It is impolite to present someone who is already in the middle of a conversation with a schedule of upcoming events.

Despite that distraction, the core message remains. The loss of Shuri is not meant to elicit tears from the audience, nor is it simply a decorative ending; it is a starting point for understanding anger while refusing to condone violence. I believe this film succeeded in conveying that distinction, but it also got bogged down in too many tangential details along the way.

So, why did this personal sorrow have to intersect with the threat posed by Namor, the underwater king who seeks to protect his people?

An injury does not constitute a justification for threats or protection

The decision to place Shuri and Namor face to face was the correct one. When you see the two of them together, it is clear that there is a distinct difference between understanding pain and condoning violence.

Namor is the king who rules the underwater kingdom of Talokan. For him, the safety of his people is not just a slogan, but a life that must be protected immediately. The film shows Shuri this world and emphasizes the importance of protecting it.

Wakanda and Talokan possess vibranium, a metal that underpins their technology and military strength. Given that various countries around the world are seeking to acquire it, Namor’s fear of exposure is understandable. It is commendable that he is motivated by a desire to protect his own nation and that he refrains from resorting to outright aggression.

The problem lies in what follows. Namor demands the conscription of the student Riri, who created a device to locate his homeland. The objective of protecting his people has been twisted into a demand that sacrifices a single student.

The fact that Riri created a dangerous technology and the claim that Namor is justified in eliminating Riri are two different things. The film portrays this difference through Shuri’s actions to protect Riri. While the king’s fear has its reasons, a student also has a life to live.

I could understand Namor here, but I couldn’t side with him. When the safety of the entire country is invoked, the life of one person seems insignificant. What Shuri is targeting is precisely that person who has been made to feel insignificant.

Scenes depicting Talokan are also necessary. If the audience doesn’t know Namor’s country, his demands will simply be seen as the orders of a villain. Knowing that there are people to protect in Talokan, we are forced to scrutinize his threats more carefully.

If one values the lives of their own people, then the lives of people from other countries must also be valued. However, Namor states that he will attack Wakanda if his proposal for joint action is rejected. The moment one denies the other party the right to refuse, the justification for protection collapses.

An alliance request that threatens to attack if rejected should be treated as a blackmail demand.

This conflict even brings up Shuri’s sadness again. Just because we showed compassion to Shuri after she lost her brother, it doesn’t mean we are pre-approving all of her future choices. We must apply the same standards to Shuri that we applied to Namor.

Therefore, I appreciate the time the two characters spend trying to understand each other. Because understanding does not automatically lead to agreement, the tension remains even as they grow closer. The performances of Light and Uerta are also excellent. They portray two people who, even as they become closer, are unable to accept the other’s demands.

The coolness of the lights does not indicate an empty seat

Letitia Wright and Tenoch Huerta portray characters who allow the audience to understand wounded individuals, but without necessarily taking sides. Thanks to the two actors, the distinction between acknowledging sadness and condoning violence becomes clear.

The strength of Wright’s portrayal of Shuri lies in the desperation to save her older brother, which later manifests as aggression. Remembering the urgency in her face at the beginning, the coldness that follows is not the result of a loss of emotion, but rather a redirection of feelings that she could not process.

Even in scenes where Shuri interacts with her mother, Ramonda, Shuri is not simply portrayed as a daughter seeking comfort. The mother and daughter, though sharing the same loss, do not grieve in the same way. Light maintains Shuri’s reserved and unyielding demeanor, even in the presence of those closest to her.

I am more drawn to characters like Shuri, who are more vulnerable than they are heroic. It is difficult to portray a character who embodies the confidence expected of royalty, and instead evokes concern about whether they can be trusted with power. This film needs that very kind of complexity.

Namor, played by Huerta, approaches Shuri with familiarity when showing her the underwater kingdom of Talokan. His willingness to share his world with her reveals a sense of affection for his own kind. Therefore, it is difficult to doubt his feelings about protecting his country.

However, the insistence on forming an alliance reveals that this closeness does not mean respecting the other party’s choices. Uerta embodies both the intimacy of guidance and the firmness of a threat within a single individual. While I understand Namor’s circumstances, I find myself more strongly opposed to his demands.

There is no need to give Shuri the right to refuse simply because she understands him. The more appealing an actor makes a character, the more critically the film must evaluate that portrayal. Uerta’s performance does not shy away from this judgment; rather, it makes it difficult and urgent.

At the Okoye Station, Danai Gurira portrays a character who embodies both the pride of a soldier and the pain of someone who has been abandoned.

Lupita Nyong’o, who plays the role of Nakia, demonstrates that pain can lead to action other than anger, through her proactive efforts to rescue Shuri and her calm demeanor.

The actors demonstrate how sadness changes a person’s behavior. The problem is that every time the film tries to follow that change, it shifts to another character.

The problem is not the length of the sadness, but the intrusion

I agree with the criticism that the mourning and the next Marvel story clash. However, I disagree if the solution is to quickly resolve Shuri’s grief.

The 161 minutes may feel long not because the grieving person is talking too much. Rather, it is because other events intrude, preventing one from fully understanding their feelings. I wanted to stay with Shuri longer, but the film constantly shifts the scene.

Riri is a student who is essential to the conflict. When Namor demands her, it reveals who is being put at risk in the name of protecting the country. Shuri’s refusal to comply carries significant weight.

Not all of the stories associated with Riri are equally important. The characters needed to initiate conflict are different from those that need to be followed for a long time. The amount of time a character stays is not always justified simply because they have a reason to appear.

The story of Ross, a character from a U.S. intelligence agency, goes further afield. While it expands the context surrounding Wakanda, it contributes little to understanding Shuri’s anger. The scope of the world expands, but the time available to follow the main character decreases.

Behind these choices lies the need to understand Shuri’s feelings again. It is not enough to simply remember what caused the pain and who was the target of the anger. To truly understand, one must experience the time when that anger was growing, and only then will the next decision become clear.

Similar problems arise in combat situations. In the latter stages of naval battles, Wakanda forces are assembled on the sea to confront a powerful enemy that excels in aquatic environments. The operation to weaken Namor individually, and the reason for leaving the rest of the forces in that location, are separate matters.

Even during the operational planning meeting, the question “Why the sea, of all places?” was not a separate agenda item.

The mere fact that fighting had begun did not fully explain the danger the soldiers were in. At the moment when I should have been following Shuri’s anger, I found myself questioning the reasons for the operation. The problem wasn’t a lack of emotion, but rather a choice that made it difficult to focus on those emotions.

I do not want to diminish the sadness in this film. I want to avoid interrupting the process by which sadness transforms into action. If this film asks the question of how far a wounded person can go, then time must be spent exploring that boundary.

To determine what should be omitted, we must first preserve the fundamental questions that have been carried over from the previous sections.

The attitude inherited from the previous installment is to understand the enemy but not to follow them

Compared to the previous installment, it becomes clear what this film did well. While acknowledging the suffering experienced by the antagonist, it does not claim that the violence he chose was justified.

In the movie “Black Panther,” the king of Wakanda, T’Challa, confronts the suffering outside his country through his adversary, Killmonger. The conflict between the two characters revolves around what powerful nations should do for oppressed people.

It is not necessary to emulate every method of Killmonger simply because one does not ignore his anger. The crucial distinction lies there. While acknowledging that the other party may be wrong does not absolve one of responsibility, feeling responsible does not necessitate condoning the other party’s violence.

Shuri and Namor also stand before the same standard. However, this time, the more urgent question is not who will share the power, but what a person who has been hurt can do with that power. The question is whether the fact of having suffered harm gives permission for a new attack.

At this point, Namor’s past is not a justification for the threats, but rather a reason to understand why he resorted to them. The same is true for Shuri’s loss. The more I understand these two characters, the more difficult it becomes to fully support anyone’s anger.

That difficulty is a good thing. If the film had made us feel satisfied even when the protagonist was harming others simply because they were sick, then the criticism of Namor would have been weakened. The film does not apply loose standards only to Shuri.

The final scene, with its depiction of farewell, makes this distinction even clearer than words can. Even without explicitly stating the choices made, one thing is certain: determining the outcome of a conflict and allowing those who remain to grieve are fundamentally different.

Therefore, I believe that Nakiya should have been given more time. His actions, returning from living outside Wakanda to rescue Shuri, demonstrate a life of helping others even while carrying pain. This was an opportunity to show, rather than simply explain through dialogue, a path different from revenge.

The short runtime prevented the film from fully exploring its themes. Nevertheless, the final scene suggests that what Shuri needed was not simply more power. Now, the question remains: is this person worth following, even with the burdens that come with it?

The detour was long, but I did not use sadness as an excuse to resort to violence

I believe that “Black Panther: Wakanda Forever” maintained a crucial distinction throughout the film. While it is important to understand the pain of losing a loved one, that pain does not grant anyone the right to harm others.

The reason for placing Shuri and Namor side by side lies in this very point. It is more important to consider who is being put at risk by making such a statement, rather than simply stating who is being protected. The film does not exempt the protagonist from this standard either.

My rating is 3.5 out of 5 stars. While Light and Uerta demonstrate that even those who want to protect others can make dangerous choices, the story falters due to the weak portrayal of the naval battles and the strained relationship between Riri and Rosro, which constantly interrupts the emotional flow. What is needed is a less fragmented, more sustained emotional experience, rather than a series of short, disconnected moments.

If you are curious about what choices a character makes after being hurt, rather than how strong they are, then this is worth your time. On the other hand, if you want fast-paced and clear action with a straightforward plot, I do not recommend it. The frequent shifts in location throughout the 161-minute runtime are a bigger obstacle than the length itself.

When watching, it is helpful to follow who Shuri and Namor say they are protecting. Also, observe who is actually put in danger because of what they say. There is a clear distinction between understanding the circumstances of the two and accepting their demands.

The next film to be discussed is “Black Panther” (2018). When comparing Killmonger and Namor using the same criteria, it becomes clear why acknowledging the enemy’s suffering and adopting the enemy’s methods are different things.

The film would have been even stronger if it had focused more on the other aspects of Naki’s life and less on the subplots. However, it did not miss the point that what was truly needed was not a larger attack. I appreciate that this film stands on the side of those who have been hurt, but does not condone their violence.

★★★☆☆ (3.5/5) — It understands those who have been hurt, but it does not necessarily take their side.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can it be understood even if you haven’t seen the previous installment?

Shuri’s struggles after losing her brother are relatable. However, to fully understand the relationships within Wakanda and Shuri’s character development, it is recommended to watch “Black Panther” (2018) first.

Is it okay to watch this if you are expecting action?

While there is combat, the central theme of this film is the choices made after loss. If you prioritize a fast-paced plot and clear combat operations, it is not recommended.

What kind of person is Namor?

He is the king who rules the underwater kingdom of Talokan. While he has a strong desire to protect his people, he demands the sacrifice of others to achieve his objective, which puts him in conflict with Shuri.

Do the character settings of Namor differ between the original comic and other versions?

The film reimagined Namor’s kingdom, replacing Atlantis with Talokan. This world, based on Mesoamerican culture, is a crucial setting for understanding Namor’s fear of protecting his people.

What should you focus on to make it more enjoyable before watching?

It is important to pay attention to who Shuri and Namor claim to be protecting. By observing who is actually put at risk because of that justification, the film makes its criteria for judging these two characters clear.

Jihoon Kim, Reporter
Editor-in-chief, ALJIstory

In-depth criticism that digs into the truth behind what you can't see

Facebook X (Twitter) Copy link