The detour was long, but grief was not transformed into a license for revenge
My rating is 3.5 out of 5 stars. I recommend this film, which, although its detours are lengthy, does not use grief as an excuse for revenge. Shuri is the younger sibling of T’Challa, the King of Wakanda who has passed away.
I watched until the end to see whom Shuri, who had failed to save her brother, would direct her anger toward. This film distinguishes between understanding a person who has been hurt and supporting that person’s aggression.
The king of the underwater kingdom of Talokan, Namor, intends to kill a student in the name of protecting his people. I commend the scene where Shuri understands his fear but refuses his demand. Riri is a student who created a detector for vibranium, the fictional metal that supports Wakanda’s technology. Namor, who wants to hide his country, demands Riri’s life because of that invention.
Can a student be killed in the name of protecting the country?
To understand Namor’s demands, one must first listen to what they fear.
Namor is not an enemy who harms others for no reason. Although he fears losing his people, Liri also has the right to live. I was glad that Shuri rejected Talokan’s demands, even after hearing about their situation.
The scene where Shuri and Namor converse in Talokan is therefore necessary. Instead of only seeing the enemies that must be eliminated, Shuri sees the people who live there. Because of this conversation, the subsequent fight felt even more uncomfortable.
Grief is not slow; the detour is long
However, when following U.S. agent Ross and the CIA, Shuri disappears for too long. It is not wrong to spend time in grief; the problem is constantly allocating that time to other things.
The story of Ross and the CIA explains how foreign powers are targeting Wakanda’s resources. However, it increasingly deviates from the narrative of how Shuri reacts and how she changes. While the story reveals more about global politics, it loses sight of the character it was initially following.
Overall: Recommended for those who are more interested in dangerous choices than in powerful heroes
If you are more interested in how the characters are affected and what choices they make than in how powerful they become, then this is worth your time. If you enjoyed the conflict between King T’Challa and Killmonger, who advocated for armed revolution, in the previous installment, then there are plenty of reasons to watch this one. I was more drawn to Shuri, who is uncertain, rather than a solid successor.
On the other hand, if you are looking for fast-paced and clear action sequences and a straightforward plot, I would not recommend this film. The frequent shifts in narrative are a bigger obstacle than the 161-minute runtime. I could have tolerated the time Shuri spends grieving.
The problem is the time spent following other events instead of her. You do not need to come to a funeral and then stay to hear the next work briefing.
When watching, it is helpful to pay attention to who Shuri and Nemer say they are protecting. Also, observe who is actually put in danger because of what they say. Even if you sympathize with their circumstances, you are not obligated to fulfill their requests.
Next, we will examine the film “Black Panther.” When placed side by side, Killmonger and Namor clearly illustrate the difference between acknowledging suffering and condoning violence. I appreciate that this film stands with those who have been hurt, but does not endorse the violence they may inflict.
Even when wearing the same white mourning clothes, the grief is not the same
I liked the white mourning clothes and the gestures at the funeral. Even within the shared mourning, Shuri’s guilt, which she bore alone, was evident.
I do not agree with the argument that the film excuses his violence simply because it spends so long explaining Namor’s circumstances. Shuri understands why they are hiding after seeing Talokan and hearing their circumstances. Nevertheless, I cannot accept the demand to kill Liri. I appreciate this rejection. The film clearly draws a line between listening to someone’s words and acting on those words to harm another person.
At the funeral, I observed the gestures of the people wearing white mourning clothes for a long time. The ceremony of sending off the king is different from Shuri’s guilt for not being able to save her brother. The film does not miss this difference, and Shuri’s anger is not seen as a sudden personality change, but as an extension of her grief.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can it be understood without watching the previous installment?
While you can follow the main plot, it’s better to watch “Black Panther” (2018) first. Understanding the relationship between T’Challa and Shuri changes the way you perceive the weight of loss. Remembering Killmonger’s anger makes the criteria by which the sequel judges violence even clearer.
Is this movie based on a true story?
This is a fictional story based on Marvel Comics characters. However, following the death of Chadwick Boseman, who played T’Challa, the film focuses on the loss experienced by the remaining characters without recasting the role. The film portrays both the real-life separation and the in-universe mourning.
What are the differences between the original comic and the adaptation?
The film changed Namor’s kingdom from Atlantis to Talokan. Talokan is an underwater kingdom based on Mesoamerican culture. This change connects Namor’s fear of protecting his people to the situation of Wakanda.
Is it okay to expect action scenes, even though the runtime is long?
Although the film is 161 minutes long, it does not rely solely on action sequences. It takes a considerable amount of time to explore themes of loss and anger, and the narrative frequently shifts to focus on various characters. If you are looking for fast-paced and intense combat, this film is not recommended.
What are the things that are good to know without spoilers?
It is important to pay close attention to who Shuri and Nemer are trying to protect. By considering the idea of protection and the people who become endangered because of it, the conflict becomes clearer. The key is to distinguish between understanding the other side’s circumstances and agreeing with their demands.