“There’s nothing new here beyond a more brutal hero.” That criticism of Black Adam misses the clash between the people and the outsiders who claim to be helping them. I found myself listening less to the protagonist as he killed his enemies than to the people challenging the heroes who came to stop him.
Kahndaq, Adam’s homeland, is a fictional country suffering under the armed group known as Intergang. Awakened from an ancient imprisonment, Adam fights by killing its soldiers. To the people, he is a liberator. To the Justice Society, an outside team of heroes, he is a threat to be contained.
Before anyone discusses how to protect the people, a disciplinary hearing for their liberator is already under way. The question is not simply how brutal Adam is. It is whether the people he claims to protect have the right to decide how that power should be used.
To me, Black Adam is a film that summons the people to judge the powerful, then lets the powerful deliver the verdict among themselves.
The Real Issue Is Not Brutality but Who Gets to Decide
The film’s most distinctive feature is not a hero who kills, but the people who are asked to judge that hero. I was more interested in whose voice gets heard first than in the force of Adam’s fists.
Adam’s methods are clearly dangerous. It is only reasonable to demand caution from someone who fights by killing his enemies. I have no desire to dismiss Hawkman’s attempt to stop the killing as hypocrisy.
The problem is the order in which that demand arrives in Kahndaq. The people have already spent years living under Intergang’s armed rule. Yet the central crisis created by the arrival of the outside heroes is Adam, not the oppression they have endured.
To the people of Kahndaq, the two forces are not equivalent. One has crushed them; the other has risen against it. The outside heroes put Adam’s danger first, while the question of why the people welcome him is pushed aside.
That does not mean every one of Adam’s killings becomes justified simply because the people cheer him on. Their applause is an understandable response, not blanket permission for everything he may do next. That gap is exactly where the film should have lingered.
Supporting Adam and having the right to challenge him are two different things. The people should be able to accept him as a savior and still oppose his next decision. Saving them once does not give him the right to make every decision on their behalf afterward.
The conflict between Adam and Hawkman is a useful starting point for this issue. Adam wants to eliminate the enemy in front of him, while Hawkman draws a line at the method he uses. Neither man is willing to yield.
But their determination alone does not reveal what the people want. If Kahndaq’s future is decided by which of the two prevails, all the people can do is accept the winner. I kept noticing who was missing from that confrontation.
That is why following only the scale of the action means missing the central conflict. The person capable of stopping Adam is not necessarily the person with the right to tell him to stop. The film becomes interesting when it recognizes that those two positions are not the same.
The character who makes that question clearest is Adrianna, the Kahndaqi woman who awakens Adam. When she challenges the intervention of the outside heroes, whose side is the film really on?
The Film Is Sharpest When Adrianna Pushes Back
When Adrianna challenges the outside heroes’ intervention, the film puts the people who need protection first. I value that choice more than any of the superhumans’ clashes.
Adrianna is the archaeologist who awakens Adam and a member of Kahndaq’s resistance. She is also a mother trying to protect her son, Amon. For her, the question of which hero is right is inseparable from her family’s immediate safety.
The outside heroes talk about the danger Adam poses. But Adrianna has been living with danger since long before they arrived. It is difficult to accept a demand that she judge Adam while ignoring the years she and her people spent under Intergang’s rule.
The film’s strength here is that it does not reduce her to a grateful civilian. She asks the people who claim to have come to save her what, exactly, they intend to save. The word “hero” does not grant them the right to evade that question.
You do not need superpowers to listen to the people you are supposedly protecting.
Her challenge also puts Hawkman’s principles under a more demanding test. Saying that killing must be stopped is right. But that principle does not excuse refusing to listen to the people caught in the middle.
At this point, I stopped taking the heroes’ claims at face value. Their ability to overpower Adam is obvious. Their right to make decisions for Kahndaq does not follow automatically.
Nor is Adrianna simply a convenient supporter of Adam. More important than the fact that she awakened him is the fact that she has people to protect. Her efforts to rescue Amon make that priority unmistakable.
What she wants from Adam, then, is not a display of strength. She needs that strength used to keep herself and her family alive. Through her, a story focused on the concerns of superhumans returns to the needs of the people.
At that point, Kahndaq becomes more than a battleground for the powerful. The people who must continue living there step forward and demand a say in what happens next. For as long as the film listens to Adrianna, it holds on to its central question with real precision.
But having the chance to speak is not the same as having the right to participate in decisions. The film cannot simply let her make her case and then declare that the people have been respected. Her demands need to shape what happens afterward.
Shahi conveys that demand with such urgency that it makes us scrutinize even more closely how the story treats the people from that point on.
The Performances Separate Power from the Need for It
Dwayne Johnson and Sarah Shahi clearly distinguish between the person who wields power and the person who needs it. Because of them, the question of whose demands are heard becomes more important than whom Adam knocks down.
As Adam, released from an ancient imprisonment, Johnson is formidable whenever he faces Hawkman. He holds an impassive expression and refuses to back down, even when confronted by someone trying to stop the killing. Before he can be persuaded with words, he rejects the demand with his body.
I like that stubborn physicality. It immediately establishes that Adam is not someone who will hand his judgment over to others. That quality makes him reassuring when he turns it against the enemies oppressing the people, but frightening when the people themselves disagree with him.
Johnson does not force those two sides apart. The attitude that refuses to bend before an enemy is also the attitude that refuses to accept anyone else’s restraint. His stubbornness supports the idea that a savior and a danger can occupy the same body.
As Adrianna, Shahi holds on to the reasons power needs to be used. When she confronts the outside heroes, she speaks from the position of someone who has lived under Kahndaq’s oppression. When she moves to rescue the kidnapped Amon, she gives that demand the urgency of a mother.
What she is protecting is not a hero’s reputation but her son’s safety. Shahi fills Adrianna’s protests with the desperation of someone who has to save her child. That is why even her rebukes of the heroes sound like demands made in defense of her family. Whenever she acts, I became newly aware of the lives caught beneath the superhumans’ argument.
What matters in the relationship between Johnson and Shahi is therefore not who overwhelms the other. One has the power to eliminate enemies; the other has a reason to demand protection. The two performers never blur that distinction.
As Hawkman, Aldis Hodge brings a firm opposition to Adam’s killings, showing that the people trying to restrain the powerful are just as certain of their own judgment.
As Doctor Fate, who can see into the future, Pierce Brosnan uses his calm manner to suggest that possessing power does not require acting in haste.
The actors distinguish these different approaches to power. But whether the people’s demands actually change the decisions being made cannot be resolved through performance alone. If that distinction is so clear, why does the movie become so familiar as it moves toward the end?
The Criticism That It Feels Familiar Becomes Fairer Later On
I disagree with the claim that the film has no new questions to ask. But I agree that it eventually covers the questions it raises with a familiar group battle.
At first, Adam and the outside heroes can hardly be on the same side. They disagree over whether killing the enemy is acceptable. It is also unclear who, if anyone, is going to speak for the people of Kahndaq.
As the film moves toward its conclusion, however, an unmistakable evil appears before them all. There is no need to spoil the enemy’s identity or the outcome of the fight. The important change is that once their opponent becomes clear, the questions they should be asking one another are postponed.
There is nothing inherently wrong with choosing to fight together. Cooperation in the face of an immediate threat to civilians is understandable. I would not want the film to keep debating principles while people are in danger.
The problem is that cooperation begins to stand in for an answer to the conflict that came before it. Attacking the same enemy does not mean everyone shares the same standards for using power. The question of what the people can demand of Adam remains unresolved.
The meeting is supposed to be about the people’s right to decide, but it ends with a joint deployment.
That choice also weakens the force of Adrianna’s earlier protest. Her words made us reconsider the heroes’ intervention. But once a common enemy appears, cooperation among the superhumans becomes more urgent than the people’s judgment.
A scene in which the heroes fight to save the people is not a scene in which the people are given decision-making power. The protected remain visible on screen, but the powerful still make the choices. The film identifies that distinction at first, then fails to explore it fully.
Part of the retreat comes from the story’s own ambitions. With Adam’s past to explain and an entire hero team to introduce, the film leaves less room to follow through on the people’s choices. But being busy does not erase the question it raised in the first place.
It is fair to acknowledge that Adrianna changes the story by awakening Adam and moving to rescue Amon. What disappoints me is that the person who sets the events in motion never gets to determine the standards by which power will be used. I wanted to see more choices in which Adrianna’s demands actually changed the powerful characters’ plans. Only then would her protest become more than a speech scolding the heroes.
That is why the second half feels disappointing less because of its familiar battles than because of the conversations it leaves out. The powerful have a reason to cooperate, but the authority the people are willing to grant them is never established. The people have every reason to welcome Adam. But if they reject him, will he listen then?
The Thrill of Punishment Is Not the People’s Permission
Black Adam captures the thrill of punishing enemies outside the law. But it does not ask deeply enough how the people are supposed to stop someone with that kind of power.
In front of people who have suffered under Intergang, Adam takes down their enemies. His power does not stop at verbal warnings; it breaks through their oppression. To deny the exhilaration of those moments would also make it impossible to explain why the people welcome him.
I, too, found Hawkman’s attempts to restrain Adam frustrating whenever Adam’s attacks worked. The film succeeds at drawing out that reaction. The problem is what happens after the rush fades: can the people really trust that power?
Putting Dirty Harry alongside it makes the question clearer. Both films center on figures who punish enemies beyond the limits of the law. They ask whether an individual may step in when established procedures fail to protect people.
But the judgment of an individual police officer and the judgment of a superhuman who can upend an occupied country do not carry the same weight. Adam’s choices do not end with him and his enemies. The people of Kahndaq still have to live there after he uses his power.
That is why the film needed to give the protected people a stronger say. Their ability to oppose Adam matters as much as their reasons for welcoming him. When he makes a decision different from theirs, who gets to tell him to stop?
The revelations about Adam’s past clearly help us understand him. I will keep the details vague, but his anger is rooted in personal loss. Even his impassive face acquires a reason for remaining so guarded.
I do not see that explanation as a mere excuse. Adam becomes more than someone with the ability to kill his enemies; he becomes a person carrying what he has lost. That gives us more reason to keep watching his choices.
But understanding is not the same as permission. Knowing Adam’s pain does not justify handing him the decisions that belong to the people. The film should have devoted as much attention to the people’s right to refuse him as it does to making us understand him.
Having a reason to use power and having permission to use it are two different documents.
Adam’s anger has a reason, and his attacks are exhilarating. I gave in to the pleasure of watching those punches land. But feeling exhilarated does not mean I am willing to hand him Kahndaq’s next decision.
He Has the Power to Save Them, but He Never Asks Permission
My verdict is that Black Adam is a film with sharp questions and familiar answers. It gives the people a voice with which to challenge their heroes, then ultimately leaves the important decisions to the powerful. The space Adrianna opens up is narrowed by the superhumans’ united battle.
Johnson’s unyielding physical performance and Shahi’s insistence on the people’s circumstances both land with force. But because the film never goes so far as to give the people the power to change the powerful characters’ decisions, I give it three out of five stars.
If you want action in which an overwhelmingly powerful hero knocks his enemies aside, the film is worth your time. Adam is especially compelling when he refuses the rules of the model hero and clashes with Hawkman. There is also real fun in watching the person saying what is right diverge from the person doing what seems necessary in the moment.
But if you expect a story that asks who will control that power after liberation, I cannot recommend it as strongly. This is not a film that follows through on exactly how much authority the people’s gratitude gives the powerful. Being grateful to someone for saving you is not the same as entrusting them with every decision that follows.
As you watch, follow not only who is stronger, but who listens to the people. In particular, pay attention to whether the superhumans’ decisions actually change after Adrianna speaks up. The film’s best and most frustrating choices emerge from the same place.
For a follow-up, I would choose Dirty Harry. It offers a useful comparison with the thrill of punishment beyond the law and the question of who granted that authority. If you watch it alongside Shazam!, focus less on who deserves to receive power than on how the person who receives it chooses to use it.
I was more interested in whether the people of Kahndaq had a place to say no to that power than in the power to save Kahndaq itself.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I watch Black Adam without knowing the DC movies?
The film explains how Adam became the person he is, so no prior viewing is essential. All you really need to know is that Kahndaq is his homeland and the Justice Society is an outside team of heroes who arrive to contain him.
Do I need to watch Shazam! first?
Not to follow the central conflict. If you watch them together, the more interesting comparison is not the connection between their magic systems, but how people who gain power choose to use it.
What kind of audience would you recommend it to?
I recommend it if you enjoy action in which a powerful protagonist overwhelms his enemies, along with clashes between heroes over matters of principle. If you want a deeper examination of how ordinary people control power, you may find it frustrating. The film raises the question, then lets a group battle take its place.
What should I pay attention to besides the action?
Do not miss the moments when Adrianna challenges the outside heroes. Follow whether the powerful actually change their decisions after she speaks. That reveals how far the film is willing to respect the people it claims to protect.
How long is the film, and is there a post-credits scene?
The runtime is 125 minutes, and there is a post-credits scene. Since the film combines character backstories with the introduction of the hero team, it is worth following not only the action but also the reasons each character chooses to use power.